Total Pageviews

Pay Pal Donation




Please consider a donation if you feel the blog has helped you. A $5 donation will help me pay for the blog artwork, guest writers, etc. $100 has been donated in May 2017. I am very honored and grateful. Dr Rich Blake

Followers

Dr Blake's Book to Learn the Secrets of successfully helping your problems

I would love you to consider purchasing my book from Book Baby publishing. The printed book goes for $79.95, but the ebook is now available for $4.99. I hope it helps many people. Thank you. Rich


https://store.bookbaby.com/book/Secrets-to-Keep-Moving-A-Guide-from-a-Podiatrist (eBook)

https://store.bookbaby.com/book/Secrets-to-Keep-Moving-A-Guide-from-a-Podiatrist1 (print)

Book image not available.

Translate

Sunday, May 21, 2017

Diabetic Foot Check

http://www.tanglewoodfootspecialists.com/library/the-right-way-to-give-yourself-a-diabetic-foot-check.cfm

Stegmann Wool Clogs for comfort and stability

A patient recommended these for comfort and stability, especially around the house. Thought I would pass it along. 

http://www.stegmanncomfort.com/stegmannwoolclogs

Hike and Bike Shoes for Immobilization of the Bend at the Forefoot

I have been using Hike and Bike shoes to immobilize the foot while not having the negative impact of a removable cast in some patients. There is one used in a plantar fascial tear for the 3 months I normally cast the foot with a removable boot. If the patient especially has a back problem, the evenness of wearing a pair of shoes like these can be great. Remember you are not able to bend your foot in push off, or it will hurt you. Therefore, it immobilizes the pull of the plantar fascia. Any metatarsal  problem could be helped by this, even if it is only part of your treatment to vary the stresses 2-4 hours a day. Sesamoid problems, turf toe, metatarsalgia or stress fractures may be helped. 

http://www.fiveten.com/us/kestrel-lace-womens-shock-blue

Saturday, May 20, 2017

Navicular Fracture: Email Advice

I am a 41-year-old single mom of two very active boys ages nine and eight. In April, I walked right off of a pedestrian sidewalk not realizing it had ended and landed right on top of and rolled my foot and ankle.

I have been in one of the immobile walking boot since 4/17. They elected not to cast immediately due to an open wound.
The fracture was only visualized on the lateral x-ray. Was not until we got the CT scan that we realize the extent of the injury.

What do you feel is my best option? The doctor feels a compression screw to attach the two pieces or six weeks in a hard cast at this point. I continue to use KT tape as well as lidocaine patches. I am in active as I can be given my current situation.

If I do get out of the house I remove my boot each time I drive and also use the knee scooter when there are long distances to travel.

Any advice or input would be greatly appreciated

































































































Dr Blake's comment: This can heal, although there is no guarantee, with casting and bone stimulator, as long as everyone agrees there is good alignment and the blood supply had not been compromised. There is just so much pressure on the fragment, and the navicular itself is known for its bad blood supply, and there is another injury at the cuboid, and as you weight bear the talus pushes against the navicular with tremendous force. You are young, and need to be active quickly with your responsibilities, so I think the surgical screws across the fragments would do you best. That being said, every injury, and especially if you have surgery, requires a lot of rehab. As a single mom, you may not have the time to dedicate, especially if there are problems or complications with the surgery. That commitment has to be worked out. Also, the fractures are the obvious, but there can be hidden injuries that will slow the recovery.  At least, as the article below points out, a simpler percutaneous screw fixation will dramatically reduce the post op recovery time over a completely open procedure. This 6 weeks post injury is important to let the soft tissue heal, and any change of infection pass, before the bone is fixated. I hope this helps some. Surgery makes sense if percutaneous where the alignment is good. Should allow activity faster overall.  But, like you should not be driving now, if the surgeon tells you some restriction, you have to oblige whatever the costs. Surgery just starts the injury over again, but the bone will heal quicker this time. Rich

http://www.podiatrytoday.com/key-insights-for-treating-navicular-stress-fractures

Tuesday, May 16, 2017

To Operate or Not: Conservative Treatment may lead to the same or better Results

All of you that have been reading this blog for awhile know my non-surgical bias. Personally, I had a bad ankle sprain 38 years that supposedly needed an operation, a herniated disc at L2/3 13 years ago that needed an operation, and torn meniscus in my right knee that needed an operation. All of these I successfully rehabbed and returned to my full activities. In practice, I see some ankle fractures that really do not need to be fixed, achilles tendons that do not need to be repaired surgically, bunions and neuromas that could get better without surgery, and tarsal tunnels that need some good nerve treatment and a supportive orthotic device. All I can say is get opinions, try alternatives as long as they are safe, do the best you can do to help (to try to avoid rotator cuff repair I am doing up to 2 hours of exercise a day now and it is working!!). 

http://www.theage.com.au/national/health/many-operations-more-harmful-than-beneficial-top-surgeon-warns-20170512-gw3pbc.html

Monday, May 15, 2017

Cross Training: 5 Reasons it can Really Help!!

I am usually one who just does one thing. I hike to count my steps or I play basketball 3 days a week, or I run 20 miles a week, but while I am doing one activity I tend to not do any others with any routine. I hope this article convinces you, like me, to cross train more with all it's benefits. 

http://running.competitor.com/2014/04/training/the-case-for-cross-training_7917

Thursday, May 11, 2017

Maximalistic Shoes and Their Biomechanics

Maximalist Footwear: A Closer Look at Biomechanical Implications
By Richard L Blake DPM



Figure 1: Hoka One One Maximalistic Shoes

     Maximalist footwear has been incredible gift for the protection of the foot. What does it mean? This category of footwear is an experiment of cushion on the walker, hiker, and runner. If we compared to a standard running, hiking, or walking shoe, the foams look oversized. Sometimes this means thicker mid soles, and they’re typically always wider which gives a wider base of support (20-30% wider than traditional)[1]. And if we were to summarize the drop from the heel to the forefoot, most maximalist shoes will be 0-8 mm drop shoes are 10-14 mm drop. These new midsole foams also tend to be lighter, initially feeling great, but can lead to durability problems. They can have built in rocker midsoles which are great for some cases of metatarsal issue, and not for others.

     If one thinks about this category of shoe the Hoke One One[2] shoe company comes to mind. But who are the players (in no particular order)?

A)     Hoka One One
B)     Brooks
C)     Skechers
D)     Adidas
E)      Puma
F)      Pearl Izumi
G)      Vasque
H)      New Balance
I)         Asics
J)       Altra
K)      Nike
L)       Scotts
Whereas traditional shoes had ranges in cushion and stability, maximalist shoes can range from very soft to firm, very light to heavy, neutral to stability, 0 heel drop to 8 mm heel drop, flexible or rigid, rocker or no rocker, narrow or wide, etc. From a pure biomechanics standpoint, this new category of shoes presents excellent choices to help her patients.

     The purpose of this article is not to help you select individual shoes for your patients. But I will try to help you deepen your relationship with the running stores which sell the shoes. How do we approach this subject? This following 17 criteria can help you with your initial recommendation. I like to think that every athlete, with all the possibilities we have, could benefit from the wearing of a standard shoe sometimes, maximalist shoe sometimes, and minimalistic shoe sometimes. If you believe in the “tissue stress model”[3] for injuries, and if you believe that each type shoe produces different stresses, our athletes may be able to mix up the stresses by alternating shoes in the same way we teach people to cross train. I think it is very important to remember that there are general rules we use, and I will discuss, in the treatment of patients. But, they are only generalizations that tend to work sometimes, always exceptions. The art of it all must be used in your experimentation.

     From a podiatrist standpoint, and I have been practicing sports medicine for 35 years, the minimalistic movement taught me 2 great things and reinforced several others. These lessons can be carried over to the maximalist shoes, which share many qualities with the minimalists. These shoes with their poster child Vibram 5 Finger taught me that it was okay to feel the ground again, and that we were probably protecting our patients too much and for too long. They taught me that various shoe categories could be worn at select times to vary the stresses in the body for an activity. And I relearned what physical therapists have been telling me for years, strengthen the foot! I am an isolation type of guy in general, I believe that to strengthen muscles ideally the muscle should be isolated. However, as long as you understand the tissue stress model, and not exercise a muscle past its micro-failure zone, the minimalistic shoes will help strengthen your foot. The minimalistic guys also taught about the strike on the ground. To be safe, a minimalistic shoe wearer should become a ballet dancer with a forefoot strike[4]. I watched so many of my knee and hip patients feel so much better with less heel strike. But, also saw so many of my patients fracture their heel, or develop severe shin splints, from remaining a heel striker.  The maximalistic shoe company Altra has all its shoes with zero drop which de-emphasizes heel strike. And both the minimalists and maximalists believe in light as possible and avoiding excess material.

     These criteria will represent typically easy evaluation points or other factors relating to their injuries, biomechanics, training experience, and weaknesses. As you evaluate the athlete, using whatever skills and questions you have, categorize them by these 17 criteria, which can help you decide on shoe gear recommendations.

#1 neutral biomechanics
#2 supination biomechanics
#3 pronation biomechanics
#4 poor shock absorption biomechanics
#5 shock absorption needs
#6 type of strike (heel, mid foot, and fore foot)
#7 balance issues (proprioception)
#8 beginning athlete
#9 experienced athlete
#10 low mileage or heavy mileage
#11 stable or unstable surfaces trained on
#12 heel height crucial biomechanics
#13 width crucial
#14 forefoot flexibility crucial
#15 forefoot rigidity crucial
#16 forefoot rocker crucial
#17 need for lightness

     So how do we look at the 17 criteria? First of all, I think it should be apparent that no one shoe will be perfect, so switching it up is important. The athlete loves to be involved in this decision making, and can see the validity in these decisions. I think it is important to have our athletes train on different surfaces, use different miles per work out, cross train, and have different shoes for different activities. You can summarize the 17 criteria into 6 main categories:

A)   Overall Biomechanics
B)   Type of activity for shoe to be worn
C)   Injury or weaknesses
D)   Type of athlete
E)    Special need from shoe
F)    Strike pattern

    The first 4 criteria should really involve gait evaluation. Any attempt to stand someone up and decide if they are neutral, pronator, supinator, or have poor shock absorption I have not found to work well. But if you can observe the athlete in the activity that they are buying the shoes for, you can usually see if they are neutral, have a tendency to supinate, have a tendency to pronate, or have shock absorption issues.

#1 Are they neutral? This is an observation that is made if they have orthotic devices or not. Basically, you watch them walk and run in what they have been using. If you are going to make them orthotic devices, or dispense OTC inserts, wait until they have those inserts. Too many of our athletes, especially the pronators, were put in anti-pronation stability shoes, even when they were neutralized with orthosis. And do not forget the power of power lacing (also called a runners knot or stability knot). Some pronators or supinators became neutral with just power lacing. The problem lies in then over-correcting someone, thus making them an unstable supinator, from a pronator. We want neutrality in general where the weight is evenly distributed as they roll through their metatarsals. So many of these cushy maximalistic shoes will take the normal motion of pronation at contact and make you a pronator. I have significant number of athletes who only really need their orthotics for these shoes to give them stability. I also have athletes that need ranges of pronation control in 2 or 3 pairs of orthotics in order to wear these shoes for some benefit.

#2 Do they have a tendency to pronate?  The subtleties for the pronators lies in the categorization of mild, moderate or severe. And this can be greatly influenced, for good or bad, by whether they wear custom or OTC orthotics. The range of shoes in resisting pronation is so extreme now, that pronation support from different orthotic devices can be needed (as mentioned in #1). I love to grade my orthotics A, B, C, D, and occasionally F for the amount of pronation or supination control I obtained. So, if a few years ago, a runner with plantar fasciitis, who pronated, got symptom relief from a B orthotic device and a stability shoe, is now wearing a super cush maximalistic shoe, and the symptoms are returning, may now need more correction to get to A, or A-, or B+. Yet they may just need some better training guidelines, or just taping and power lacing, or a slight varus wedge under the medial aspect of the orthotic device they already have. Whatever works for them is okay and I love to practice KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) when I can. And I explain all this to them. They are typically every passionate about their activity, and love this knowledge.

#3 Do you have a tendency to supinate? This can be from pes cavus, weak peroneals, unstable lateral columns, tibial varum, etc. And for the 10-15% of you who are supinators, I have not found over-the-counter orthotics to work well and even custom orthotics (unless designed for supination) can put too much on the arch and throw them laterally. Whereas some pronation is still okay, some supination can be deadly. The same adage is true in both bunion surgery and foot biomechanics: Thou shall not varus! Again the subtleties for the supinators is a categorization of mild, moderate, and severe. For those of you Root trained, or Kinetic Wedge trained, or Maximally Pronated trained, you will understand not to supinate. Maximalistic shoes that are really stacked (some of the Hoka One One shoes I know have a 36 mm midsole) can take a neutral patient, or pronator, and begin to lean outward (especially due to the durability impact of lateral heel strike, the use of orthotic devices for some symptoms, and the need of the shoe to be light and soft). Image 2 shows this tendency in only 100 miles. I would recommend a monthly counter top check of how the shoe is leaning for your patients to do at home. There are 17 plus common pain syndromes associated with over supination. Typically their original symptoms feel better, but they can begin to complain of other symptoms like peroneal, ilio-tibial band, or medial knee compartment from jamming.

Figure 2: The left Hoka One One shoe is leaning out making a pronator into a supinator.

#4 Do you have poor shock absorption? These are the pounders. Some just have too much heel strike. This does not have to do anything about their weight. They can be supinators also, since you need some pronation for shock absorption. Or they can function maximally pronated, it is the motion of pronation that absorbs shock not the position.  Some people are good at observing excess shock, sometimes it is how hard a person hits the ground, and sometimes it is just that they have knee arthralgia or hip arthralgia or lower back symptoms and the pounding should be minimized. I think the general concept behind maximalistic is shock absorption.

#5 Do you have shock absorption needs? The ultra-marathoners who wear this shoe type believe the added shock absorption is saving their joints during these long runs. I think by definition if you are an ultra-marathoner, you are a poor shock absorber. You need the extra protection, common sense. But, it may be the runner or walker, with too much cement activities, or some vitamin D deficiency, or other forms of inadequate bone health. It could merely be the novice cross country runner whose bones are not used to the pounding or torqueing.

#6 What type of strike do you have? Is it heel strike, midfoot, or forefoot? For years I have been trying to get my heel strikers to get more solid and stable by landing on their midfoot (really should be whole foot). I would refer them to the website or YouTube videos on Chi Running which is all about mid foot landing and a stable body above your foot. With all the variations you will find in maximalistic shoes in terms of these wide bulky midsoles and uni-bottoms, Chi Running has helped patients land on a more stable surface. 



Figure 3: The typical wide out-flared soles which can cause stability issues with heel strikers

I usually have found mid foot strikers the most stable, with the heel strikers and forefoot strikers less predictable. They can be very smooth, or violently unstable, or something in between. I have had to make custom orthotic devices to stabilize the instabilities more in heel strikers or forefoot strikers, and there is less of the foot to use in a forefoot striker.

#7 Do you have balance or proprioception issues? Of course, this can be from many causes. There are 5 levels to a typical single leg balancing evening routine for our patients to work through. You do not have to be in a highly stacked maximalistic shoe with balance issues to enjoy the benefits of the cushion. The photo below shows a several stability, and not too high, Adidas NMD CS1. Or if you or your patient is really unstable and walks on uneven ground, try one of the maximalistic hiking boots.


Figure 4: The Adidas NMD CSI with added stability plugs and lower stack heights.

This puts our discussion into the next group of criteria: the type of athlete you are. As you all know, AMA recently upped its daily walking minimum to 15,000 steps. This is 2 and ½ hours for me, a relatively low walker. But, to my classification, it means all walking to these levels is very athletic. You runners cannot scoff at the walkers as much. It is getting us out of the house, off the couch, and into the roads. Here is where a stable foundation, one where maximalistic shoes can shine with their great shock absorption, can perhaps beat back the onslaught of obesity and diabetes and cardiac conditions. It is another tool is our box, and a good one at that.

#8 Are you a beginning athlete? If you are just starting to walk, have a good pair of maximalistic shoes to wear for your longer walks, and traditional neutral running shoes for your shorter walks. Running shoes in general have more support and cushion than walking shoes in general. With only 50% of people who start a walking program, and 30% a running program, still going in 2 years, it is crucial you take this seriously (and your podiatrist who recommends it). It you cannot find a store with a good selection and exchange rate familiarize yourself with the great surface and ability to experiment with Zappos or RoadRunnerSports.

Figure 5: Good Neutral Shoe from Skechers with great forefoot flexibility and good shock absorption


#9 Are you an experienced athlete? Experienced athletes are typically more aware of their bodies and have a good base of exercise which has strengthened them. They can definitely get away with more training errors, like improper shoes, hurried training programs, etc., since their threshold for overuse injury is higher. Experienced athletes should be very much used to cross training, and already know if they need neutral or stability shoes. I believe all experienced athletes, especially as we age, should get familiar with this latest brand of cushion shoe. It may be of great help in increased stress environments as so many ultramarathons attest. Several of the negatives of being an experienced athlete are 1) may take more risks feeling a bit too invulnerable, and 2) get to set in your ways and not vary things up enough. Maximalistic shoes can be a way to vary a workout, without much psychological change.

#10 Are you low mileage or high mileage? Whatever you do, low mileage is less stressful, and less need for the added cushion of a maximalistic shoe. High mileage walkers, hikers, or runners, need to daily vary the terrain, the distance, and the type of shoes they wear. I know this article is about maximalism, but the group of experienced (more than 3 years) high mileage athletes tend to do great with a workout or two a week with minimalism.

#11 Do you train on stable versus unstable environments? This is where I can get nervous with a stacked high maximalistic shoe with unstable ankles and uneven terrain. The problem typically comes when you did not expect the terrain change, or you were day dreaming. All the maximalistic shoes can accommodate an ankle brace when needed.

Finally, maximalistic shoes allow for a wide variety of individual needs to be met when dealing with injuries. There are times we want heel height or no heel height, very wide or narrow, forefoot flexibility or rigidity, forefoot rocker or not, or very light or standard. There are maximalistic shoes that fit all these specs.

#12 Is the heel height level crucial? Most agree with the minimalists that metatarsal, knee, and sometimes hip pain felt better in a low heel, and Achilles, plantar fascia, and shin splints loved a higher heel. The maximalistics are all over this with cushion and high 8 mm heels and zero drop heels (like in the Altra complete line of shoes).

#13 Is the width crucial? In general, I personally think they are either too wide (Altra line) or too narrow (Hoka One One line), but with power lacing, orthotics, etc., I can typically make it work. Most biomechanics people I know believe the front can be a little loose, as long as the mid part of the shoe is stable on the foot.

#14 Is the forefoot flexibility crucial? The image below shoes the forefoot flexibility test that was standard for traditional shoes. Some maximalistic shoes are very flexible, and this can be an important factor in someone’s injury.


Figure 6: Maximalist Altra Olympus showing good forefoot flexibility



#15 Is the forefoot rigidity crucial? You make the shoe rigid so it acts like a cast. You can have your patients buy a carbon graphite plate, like those sold at Otto Bock, if they already have the shoe you want. The more rigid, the more stable the overall shoe becomes.

#16 Is a forefoot rocker crucial? This is different than just being rigid. It actually allows for the normal roll of the foot like a removable boot. For some conditions, like sesamoid issues, this roll can allow the boot wearer to get into shoes more quickly. It needs a high stack however, so the negatives of some instability and durability issues may be of concern. The removable boots we have our patients wear actually prolong the weight bearing of the heel and forefoot versus traditional shoes sometimes increasing pain in these areas you are trying to fix. Same possibility is present when you use a rocker shoe.

#17 Do you need lightness? This new batch of foams that make maximalistic shoes are light. Who doesn’t love that? Probably great for joints, but watch for durability issues.



[1] Metzler, Brian, Sole Man: 12 Things About Maximalist Shoes, Competitor.com
[2] Beer, Brad, Hoka Running Shoe Review-Hype or Helpful?, https://www.pogophysio.com.au/blog/hoka-running-shoe-review/
[3] McPoil, Thomas G. and Hunt, Gary C., Evaluation and Management of Foot and Ankle Disorders: Present Problems and Future Directions, JOSPT, Volume 21, Number 6, June 1995, pages 385-388.
[4] Ellingsen, Linda, Barefoot/Minimalist Running Basics, https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/basics-of-barefoot-minimalist-running.html

Sesamoid Fracture: Email Advice

Dear Dr. Blake, 

I hope you are well and thank you for your great book, blog and guidance that have been instrumental during this challenging time.

I have seen a few doctors and have felt that your book and blog were the most informative and caring/humane and that is why I am reaching out to you desperately at this critical point in my life.  It would mean the world if you can let me know your thoughts, insight and valuable advice, and of course this can be shared on your blog to benefit everyone.

Summary:
- Athletic and active 31 year old individual trying to get his life back
- Pain on and off for over a year under big toe
- Sudden sharp pain end of December 2016 while walking
- Increasing pain, saw doctor few months later in 2017, X-Ray Feb 25 (attached): Left medial sesamoid fracture.
No obvious fracture to the sesamoid can be seen on AP view

Plantar Axial View clearly shows the break and sclerosis (over whitening) seen in Avascular Necrosis


March 22 started complete non-weight bearing (NWB) with crutches and had foot in walking boot with barely any foot/toes movement for 6 weeks (believe this probably wasn't the best path to take after reading your book and blog recently)
Dr Blake's comment: After all the walking you did not knowing you had a fracture, the fracture fragments are together, so it is not considered unstable. Some believe in non weight bearing for a time to let fragile bone elements get stronger, a theory, but I also find that the bone demineralization and swelling build up from non weight bearing which may cause 3 months of soreness for 6 weeks off the ground.  Then, after the 6 weeks, it is hard to evaluate the symptoms accurately. 
- Used to wear Dr. Scholl's flat feet soft orthotics in regular shoes, and the person that provided me with the boot attached a rubbery material to harden/lift the arch even more and cut out the part under the sesamoid so that it floats (image attached).

- MRI Taken on April 16 (after ~3.5 weeks in NWB).
- X-Ray taken on May 2 attached (after 6 weeks NWB)
- Saw doctor on May 3 (6 weeks NWB) and MRI report and video with images (file can be opened using Google Chrome) attached
Avascular Necrosis of left medial sesamoid
Plantar Plate Tear



Bone Demineralization from Non Weight Bearing

Arrow pointing to Intact Plantar Plate Ligaments

Arrow pointing to Massive Bone Edema ?Avascular Necrosis of Tibial Sesamoid


History:
Flat feet, overpronation, previous left ankle sprain several years back (no fractures), other than that healthy

Goal:
I would like to bring my sesamoid bone back to life if possible without aggravating the fracture and hopefully healing it at as well and getting back to normal active life.

Based on reading your book/blog, here are my proposed next steps and please let me know if you would prefer any alteration/addition.

Next Steps:
- Ordered Exogen bone stimulator to start asap, 3x day: morning, lunch, evening.
Dr Blake's comment: Twice daily fine!
- Starting Contrast baths
Dr Blake's comment: Start with 1 min hot and 1 min cold alternating each for a total of 20 minutes each evening. As you feel better, see if you can progress to 2 hot 1 cold for 18 minutes without feeling like the joint is getting stiffer. 
- Physio Therapy (PT) in the morning before work, workout with upper body weights and stationary bike in the evening after work
- Setting an alarm for every 30 mins just to move my ankle around (and toes?) a little throughout the day 
Dr Blake's comment: Excellent, definitely can not hurt yourself with moving your toes on your own. Don't forget using oil or gel to massage your foot for 2 minutes three times a day to de-sensitize the nerve over-reaction of protection. 
- 1 week partial weight bearing in boot w/ help of crutches, then get Evenup for other foot and walk in boot.
Dr Blake's comment: Get some 1/4 inch adhesive felt (moore medical) and make a dancer's pad for the foot of one or two layers to float the sesamoid some.

- Continue Calcium, Mg, and Vit. C and D supplementation with healthy diet

Questions please:
- Do I have a good chance?
Dr Blake's comment: For sure. One of my concerns is the plantar plate tear. Did you have a fall, the only way to tear at your age, or is this an other read? It will take 9 months or bone stimulation, contrasts, good bone health, and keeping the pain level between 0-2 in the healing range. You have to be willing to take the sesamoid out if it does not work, and it can take one year or so to figure it out. May need some help from friends to keep you focused. Have a surgeon picked out in your mind, but vow internally that you are going to prove you will not use their help. This is what I would do for myself. 
- Do I take any blood thinners to help blood flow for AVN, ex: aspirin?
Dr Blake's comment: Never heard of that research, so probably not. 
- I do not see swelling or feel pain (unless I press w.finger on sesamoid there is some). Do I need to ice? Not sure what is best given AVN and want to promote blood flow.  If iceing then how long and freq. please?
Dr Blake's comment: Icing gets a bad wrap on stopping blood flow, which is only temporarily. Read about Hunting Phenomenon below. 5-10 minutes is all you need to quiet the inflammatory aspect twice daily. 
http://www.sportsinjuryclinic.net/treatments-therapies/cryotherapy-cold-therapy/effects-cryotherapy-cold-therapy

http://www.sportsinjurybulletin.com/archive/1066-cryotherapy.htm

- Contrast baths, do I end with hot water to promote vasodilation?
Dr Blake's comment: No, always end with 1 minute of ice. Hopefully, the 2 articles above will help you understand icing or cyrotherapy better. 
- Spica taping? Any other foot or toe limiting movements I should apply?
Dr Blake's comments: If I ask 20 patients with this problem what is crucial, there would be 4 distinct camps. 5 would say spica taping is crucial, 5 would say Cluffy Wedges are crucial, 10 would say dancer's padding is crucial, 5 would say custom orthotics are crucial. Just got to try everything to see what is crucial for you. 
 Any while sleeping?
Dr Blake's comment: Typically nothing is needed. 

- Move toes around? Piano and other toe moving exercises? Both plantar flexion and dorsiflexion are good and won't deter healing or just stick to plantar flexion and ankle and 
 leg exercises?
Dr Blake's comment: We have to avoid impact stress, like jumping down hard, or forceful push off, but moving of the toes, ankles, knees, and most exercises can be slightly modified to take pressure off (like dropping your sesamoid into a hole made of four books so you can do balancing or stretches, or putting the weight in the arch with the pedal when stationary biking). Just listen to your body. But we need motion, some weight bearing, strength, cardio, etc. 
- When sleeping do I elevate foot on a pillow or does it press on calf muscle and limit blood supply?
Dr Blake' s comment: It depends how it feels in the morning. Swelling up or down. If down, no need to do anything. If up, try books between the boxstrings and mattress at the foot of your bed, and gradually raise up. Try 1 inch to start. 
- I am wearing a thin dancer's pad as well stuck to foot, do I keep that on?
Dr Blake's comment: Yes, you will be wearing dancer's pads for a long time. Typically, people can figure out how to attach it to the shoe or shoe insert. Here is where you buy a roll of the 1/8th inch adhesive felt to make your own. 
https://www.mooremedical.com/Index.cfm?Ntk=all&No=0&Search=Search&Ns=TotalRevenue%7C1&Ntx=mode+matchpartialmax&Ntt=Adhesive+Felt

- Would I do Exogen before or after the following: icing, contrast bath, PT, exercise?  Any particular order you would recommend for all these to make sure I promote blood flow and healing?
Dr Blake's comment: Icing after you do walking or exercises that you think may irritate things. Contrast baths usually in the evening as a deep flush to daily move out the swelling trapped in there. Exogen twice typically early am and before bed. 
- Massaging foot? just pressing hands (and on sesamoid too?) or shall I get a foot roller (any recommendations?)?
Dr Blake's comment: At this point, I would gradually increase pressure with your 2-3 times daily sesamoid and total foot massage just with your palms. You will have to go lightly around the sesamoid at first, but it is vital to de-sensitize the nerves to be right on the sesamoid area. 
- Cluffy wedge for now or later down the line or not needed?
Dr Blake's comment: Now, and as long as need that protection. Sometimes, it is hard to tell initially, but so many of my sesamoid sufferers swear by it. It may be more important when you are taking more normal steps. 
- How long in boot before transitioning to post-op shoe, then how long after that to hard-soled shoe?  If I insert carbon graphite inserts in my regular shoes, will these be too harsh on sesamoids? If not when can I do that?
Dr Blake's comment: The post op shoe is if you can not take any weight transfer onto the sesamoid, so that can be first or never. The boot, with an built in dancer's pad (sometimes up to 1/2 inch float, is more the starting point. Hard soled shoes can be a long time away, with soft soles (like Hoka One One with a Rocker, or Altra Olympus with just cush and zero heel height (drop)). There is a lot of experimenting that can be done as you begin to get comfortable walking in the boot, and you know on the horizon as shoes. Get familiar with Road Runner Sports and Zappos. These are online places with great policies on shipping and returns. 
- Boot is large, shall I bike in socks and put weight on arch/heel, or bike in post-op shoe at this stage?
Dr Blake's comment: Start with weight on heel initially, and after 5 times, and if you are feeling good with that, try a few times with the weight in the arch. As the weight goes into the arch, there is a little more pull on the tissue that attaches to the sesamoid. You can not hurt it, but the extra pull may be irritative right now. 
- Is Evenup high enough to balance other side of body? Purchasing one right away as already feeling a little hip aching?
Dr Blake's comment: Yes, there are 2 parts to the EvenUp, and one can be removed if the EvenUp is too high initially. Women typically have little problem finding a shoe with the correct heel height. More struggle for men. 
- When would I start acupuncture vs dry needling? which one?
Dr Blake's comment: Technically, they are the same, although many practitioners separate the nerve part and the muscle part. It is up to the skill and purpose of the practitioner. I always feel acupuncture is one of the best ways at increasing blood flow, increasing our body's own immune system, and desensitizing nerves. So, if given a choice, I tend to recommend acupuncture. Dry needling, is really acupuncture, but used for muscles more I think. 
- X-ray followups how often roughly? F/up MRI in 3 months? CT scan?
Dr Blake's comment: I would get a CT scan now to get the bone health. I would get a followup MRI 6 months after the first one to check progress. 

Any other advice or your usual inspirational words would help a lot and I really appreciate your valuable insight and support during this difficult time.

You're a life-saver, sorry for the long email and thank you from the bottom of my heart.

Sincerely, 

Dr Blake's comment: I looked at the MRI he sent by Google Drive, pretty cool that it can be done that way, and saw massive joint swelling which can wash out the visualization of the ligaments (so I emailed him to get a feel if there was any chance he could have torn his plantar plate). You could definitely see the sesamoid fracture with healing edema. 


Thank you very much for looking into it Dr. Blake. No high impact activities or falls. First time I had ever felt some minor pain in this area was a few years ago after walking around for a few hours in the city wearing very thin shoes.  Following that long walk, I had on and off pain every now and then in both feet, more prominent in the left.  I also think I might have not be walking correctly since I had sprained my left ankle several years back and was advised by a physiotherapy student/friend to put my weight on the area under the big toe while walking.  I have very flat feet and overpronation naturally though and have been wearing the Dr.Scholl's OTC orthotics pictured in my original email.  I used to play a lot of soccer but haven't been playing for over a year.  Before NWB I was going regularly to the gym to workout (5x per week): lift weights and bike, eliptical and run on the treadmill (~10 minutes each at high speed).  The night before the day I got the sharp sudden pain (fracture I believe) I was squatting a little heavier than I usually do at the gym, not very heavy weights though around a total of 160 pounds.  I was healthy and eating well with a daily Centrum multivitamin and at least a glass of milk a day. It was winter and I would probably go weeks with no sunlight at all though (work indoors most of the day and cold and cloudy weekends usually).  It was around Christmas and I had received winter boots as a gift and they were actually pretty tight on my toes, and the sudden sharp pain (fracture) hit me while wearing these after wearing them for about a week.

Thanks again for asking and that's all I can think of.  

Kindest regards,